Apple Watch Syncing Issue
-
I am a heavy user of the watch app. I pretty much leave my phone at home all the time when I run/walk and stream podcasts to my watch over cellular. I definitely like the recent improvements you have made for instant syncing between the iPhone and watch. However, I’ve noticed an issue that impacts me almost every day. I stream the podcasts and don’t pre-download them to save space on my devices. I noticed if I start a new podcast on my watch while on cellular away from my phone and don’t finish the episode by the time I return home, my progress will not be synced to my phone. When I launch the phone app, it will show the episode I started while out on a run, but the progress will be at 0:00. Then if I go back to the watch app to see where I left off, it has also been reset back to 0:00.
Steps to reproduce:
- Make sure downloading on phone and watch are disabled so all episodes stream
- Move out of range of the phone so the watch is on cellular (I haven’t tested to see if this happens on WiFi yet)
- Start a new podcast which you haven’t listened to (so progress hasn’t already been synced)
- Listen for a while
- Return to your phone
- Stop the podcast on your watch
- Launch the app on your phone
- The episode will appear in the mini player, but progress will be reset to 0:00 on all devices
-
Also confirming that this problem happens when starting a podcast on WiFi as well, not just cellular.
-
After further testing – the connection doesn’t even matter. It can be Bluetooth, WiFi or cellular. As long as the podcast is started on the watch, it does not sync its progress to the phone.
-
Hi there,
Thanks for the clear steps, and for testing it on Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and cellular. That rules out the connection: the problem follows episodes you start on the watch, and both devices then fall back to 0:00.
This is a bug, and I couldn’t find an existing report of it, so I’ve passed your steps to our iOS developers. I can’t give you a date for a fix, but once it’s in, updating both apps is all you’ll need to do.
Something to try in the meantime
From your steps, episodes that already have some progress synced don’t seem to be affected. So before heading out, start a new episode on your phone for a few seconds, pause it, then pick it up on the watch. I haven’t been able to confirm this works, so let us know either way.
Logs would help our developers
The next time it happens, before you play anything else, please email us the logs from both devices:
- Open Pocket Casts on your Apple Watch and leave it open.
- On your iPhone, go to Profile > Help & Feedback, tap the three-dot icon in the top right, then tap Logs.
- With iOS selected at the top, tap the share icon and email the log to (email visible only to moderators and staff).
- Switch to watchOS and send that log the same way.
In the email, add a link to this thread, the episode title and roughly when you started and stopped it, so we can match the logs to your report.
One question too: does it also happen with an episode that’s downloaded to the watch, or only with streamed ones?
-
Hey – thanks for the response and for looking into this issue! I can confirm that starting a podcast on the phone before switching to the watch does work. When I return, the progress will be updated correctly. I use this as a workaround if I’m listening to a long podcast. But typically, I’ll have a few queued up before going out and as soon as one finishes, the next one starts from the beginning on the watch and then I’ll hit the issue again.
I have not tried downloading the podcast first, but I will test that soon and reply here. I will send logs as well.
Thank you!
-
Hi there,
Thanks for testing that, and good to know starting on the phone works. You’re right that it stops helping as soon as your queue moves on to the next episode by itself.
Until there’s a fix, you can stretch the same workaround over your whole queue. Before heading out, play each episode in your Up Next on your phone for a few seconds and pause it, so every one has some progress saved. Start with the last episode in the list and work up to the first: each episode you play moves to the top of Up Next, so going from the bottom up leaves your queue in its original order. It’s an extra step, but it should cover a run with several episodes queued.
Thanks too for testing a downloaded episode and sending logs. Your results will help our developers narrow it down. When you email the logs, include a link to this thread so we can match them to your report.
-
Just wanted to give you a quick update that I tried downloading a podcast (the same episode on both the phone and the watch) first, then repeating the same steps and when I came back to the phone, the progress was still at 0:00. So whether I stream or download the episodes, it doesn’t seem to make a difference.
For the logs, do you want me to send them as soon as I see the progress has gone back to 0:00 on both?
-
Logs sent.
Here’s another interesting piece of info I’ve observed. When the iPhone app first opens and syncs, the mini player updates to reflect the podcast I was on and it does show the correct progress initially on the mini player. However, if I open the full player, the progress shows 0:00.
So then I tried again with a different podcast, launched the iPhone app, waited for the mini player to show the correct progress. This time I didn’t open the full player, I just tapped play on the mini player. Despite showing the correct progress it still started the podcast over from the start.
Hopefully this gives the engineers a better idea of where to look for the issue.
-
Hi there,
Thanks for the logs and for your note about the mini player and full player. Together they show what’s going wrong.
When you pause on the watch, your position does reach the phone, but the episode stays marked as not started there. As soon as the phone picks that episode up from your Up Next, it treats it as new and puts it back to the beginning, then passes 0:00 back to the watch.
That’s why only episodes started on the watch are affected. An episode you’ve started on the phone is already marked as in progress, so your place is kept. It’s also why streaming, downloading and the type of connection make no difference.
I’ve added these details to our bug report for our iOS developers. I can’t give you a date for a fix, but once it’s in, updating both apps is all you’ll need to do.
Until then, playing each queued episode on your phone for a few seconds before heading out remains the best workaround. You don’t need to run any more tests, and thanks for all the help narrowing this down.
-
Sounds good! I definitely appreciate the attention to this and will be looking forward to the fix. If there’s anything else you need, please don’t hesitate to reach out!
-
Thanks for all the testing, and for spelling out the mini player detail. That one was especially useful.
Everything you sent is now with the team that works on the iPhone and Watch apps. Until the fix is in an app update, playing each episode on your phone for a few seconds before you head out is still the way to keep your place.
If you notice it happening in a new way, or it starts working again after an update, just post here.